Spring Sale
Days
Hours
Min
Sec
x
Wood vs. MDF in Your Kitchen

When it comes to selecting kitchen cabinets, a common dilemma arises between wood and MDF (medium-density fiberboard). Both materials come with their set of advantages and disadvantages, making the decision a careful balance between budget, design preferences, and long term functionality. This article will explore the strengths and weaknesses of each material to provide you with the knowledge for making an informed choice about using them in your kitchen.


Wood Cabinets

Solid wood has been the top choice for kitchen cabinets for centuries, and with good reason. Of course early on it was the only material, but it stuck around because of its inherent strength and durability. It can support heavy dishes and appliances and look good doing it. Oak, cherry, and maple are among the popular types of wood for kitchen cabinetry, each showcasing unique grain patterns that add warmth and character to any kitchen. Solid wood is also considered an investment as it tends to increase in value over time while potentially lasting for generations with proper care.

The undeniable allure and longevity of wood do come at a cost. Expect to pay more, compared to MDF, for these natural masterpieces. Solid wood also demands upkeep in order to maintain its immaculate condition, but with proper care you can avoid needing to do bigger repairs later. Sanding, staining, and occasional refinishing may be necessary, but the worst of it can be avoided if you treat your cabinets well day by day.

Solid wood surpasses MDF in its resistance to moisture, but excessive humidity can lead to warping or cracking. A good moisture-proof wood finish will be necessary to help your cabinets withstand the inevitable humidity in a steamy kitchen. Thankfully, it’s easy to find pre-finished cabinets that can do the job.


MDF Cabinets

MDF is a composite material made from wood fibers and resin. It’s a low-cost, versatile material that offers a smooth surface ready for painting, which works well to achieve contemporary and minimalist aesthetics. It also comes in a range of colors and finishes so painting may not even be required. In comparison to wood, MDF is considerably more affordable, making it an enticing choice for homeowners on a budget.

While MDF undeniably has some advantages, it's crucial to acknowledge its limitations. MDF lacks the same inherent strength as solid wood and may be prone to dents and scratches, especially in high traffic areas. Its sleek surface can peel if not properly maintained, and repairing of all but the lightest damage is next to impossible. Additionally MDF tends to absorb moisture more readily than solid wood does, making it even more vulnerable to the typical environment in a kitchen. Because of how MDF is made, even slight cosmetic damage can allow moisture inside and compromise the integrity of the whole structure (much like the issues with laminate cabinets).


Making the Decision Between Wood and MDF in the Kitchen

The decision between wood and MDF should revolve around your specific needs and preferences, but you really need to understand the pros and cons of each one. Consider these factors when deciding on the right material:

Cost and Investment

The undeniable strength, beauty, and longevity of wood come at a higher price compared to MDF. Be prepared for an investment — but remember that in this case it really is an investment since high-quality genuine wood cabinetry in a kitchen is one way to help build equity in a home. You can also offset the cost of even the best cabinetry by choosing RTA (ready to assemble) cabinets rather than pre-assembled. MDF is a more affordable option, but is more likely to need outright replacement later and doesn’t add value like wood does.

Durability

Solid wood is the winner when it comes to long-term durability, while MDF needs to be closely monitored for damage and may not withstand heavy use as well. A deep scratch in a wooden surface is annoying, but such a scratch in MDF could end the life of the cabinet, especially if it’s not noticed right away and moisture has time to infiltrate.

Maintenance

Both need maintenance, the amount of which will vary depending on the amount of use it gets and where it is in your kitchen. Maintenance includes cleaning and potential minor repairs. Cleaning is pretty easy if you do it often enough to prevent the worst grime from building up, often coming down to just wiping everything down as part of your daily routine. Minor repairs, such as filling in dings or scratches, are much easier with wood than with MDF, though.

Design

Wood is often chosen for its natural beauty, but can also be painted to match any kitchen if you’re not interested in the appearance of woodgrain. MDF comes in a lot of options for modern and contemporary styles, but if you do want natural-looking wood, trying to simulate grain by painting it on MDF can make you look silly and cheap. MDF’s “natural” look is a mildly unpleasant cardboard-ish brown, so it pretty much needs to be painted whereas wood can provide either a slick painted surface or that timeless natural grain.

Environmental Impact

Both materials have sustainability implications, but solid wood has an ecological advantage: it’s much less likely to need replacement within a few years, meaning less waste and less energy spent manufacturing. The wood should be responsibly sourced, too, such as from a company that ensures replanting of trees, and it’s much easier to find out where your wood is coming from than for MDF which is so much more artificial.


The Verdict on Wood Versus MDF

By looking at the points above, wood comes out ahead in almost every circumstance. Its only “downside” seems to be price, and even that becomes less of an issue in the long run (and can be mitigated with smart purchase decisions like choosing RTA). Well-maintained solid wood can pay for itself when compared to MDF.

However, this doesn’t mean there’s no place for MDF in the kitchen at all. It can be a perfectly good choice for anything that doesn’t require the strength and resilience of wood, or is located in a place that shields it from most potential damage. Just because there are better options for cabinets doesn’t mean you need to avoid MDF entirely. Cabinets are just such a big part of the kitchen, and have such potential for increasing your home’s value, that they are not something you should skimp on — not to mention that low-quality cabinets can even be dangerous, or risk the destruction of other items in your kitchen if they fail.

If you do choose wooden cabinets, keep in mind that the construction methods matter as much as the material. Avoid any manufacturer that uses cheap construction or components or otherwise cuts corners. It’s a good idea to learn about the best cabinet construction methods so you have a standard to compare against.

Add Comment

?

NEWSLETTER SIGNUP